Great Eats at Underdog Bar in FIDI!

I recently had the pleasure of visiting Underdog Bar in the Financial District of NYC. Going downtown is always and Underdog is a delicious one. They specialize in craft cocktails and offer great menu items to pair along.

I started off with the Black Shuck cocktail, made with Jameson Black Barrel, Black Dirt Apple Brandy, Black Walnut, Punt E Mes, Mole, and Maple. It’s smooth for a cocktail that has so much in it, and I really enjoyed it with the Housemade Chips with Blue Cheese Sauce. Alongside the Black Shuck, I also tried the Roaring Lion with Angostura Rum, Pineapple Rum, Amaro, Homemade Cola, and Champagne.

The menu here has great bar bites, including the Lamb Flatbread, which is topped with arugula and warm cheese. This dish easily paired with the Irish Wit cocktail, made with Jameson Whiskey, Banana, Lillet Blanc, Island Orgeat, Lemon, and Belgian Whit Beer. This cocktail was honestly one of the best ones I have had in a while. I didn’t know what to expect when combining Jameson, Lillet, and Beer, however, the combination works so well, you wouldn’t even know you’re drinking all of those ingredients! For a larger plate, I decided to try the Bone Marrow, which was absolutely delicious. This savory dish paired with the Dublin Milk Punch, made with Tullamore Dew, Guinness, White Wine, Clarified Milk, Lemon, and Nutmeg.

For those of you looking for a great bar, with a lively atmosphere, then head to Underdog Bar. The menu here is great for people who enjoy elevated bar food, with a tavern vibe. Check them out at 55 Stone Street, New York, NY. 

Sara Lehman

About Sara Lehman

Sommelier, Private Chef, & Food and Wine Pairing Expert in NYC! Sara is a Wine Writer, Wine Ambassador, and Wine Consultant specializing in pairings, parties, entertaining and education.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.